HiFiBerry follow up

11.06.2017 20:59

Back in December I was writing about problems with a HiFiBerry audio interface for Raspberry Pi. The audio board was apparently emitting interference on the 2.4 GHz frequency band and made the wireless LAN connection on the Raspberry Pi unreliable. I got in contact with their support and they acknowledged that the oscillators on that version of their hardware had an EMI problem. They promised to get back when they've fixed the issue and indeed in April they offered to replace the old board free of charge or sell me a new one for half the price. I opted for the latter option, since I was curious what changes they made to the design and wanted to compare the boards side-by-side.

HiFiBerry DAC+ HW 2.2

This is the old board, marked HiFiBerry DAC+ HW 2.2. The components marked with X44 and X48 are Fox Electronics Xpresso-series hybrid oscillator modules. Each of these contains an integrated circuit and a quartz crystal resonator. Unfortunately they are unmarked and I didn't bother to measure their frequency. From their designations I'm guessing one provides the clock for the 44100 Hz sampling rate and the other for 48000 Hz. Datasheet for the PCM5122 ADC suggests that the oscillators themselves are in the 10 MHz range and the clocks are then divided down inside the ADC chip.

HiFiBerry DAC+ HW 2.6

This is the new board I got. It's marked HW 2.6. The gold hybrids have been replaced with similar looking components in black plastic packages. Xpresso-series has apparently been discontinued. The new oscillators are marked only with letters BOHXA and after a brief web search I didn't manage to find their manufacturer. The new board also omits the push-button. I'm not sure what its original function was anyway.

Here are the two photographs superimposed to highlight the differences:

Comparison of HiFiBerry DAC+ HW 2.2 and 2.6

Apart from the new oscillator hybrids the most obvious change is the removal of two large copper fills on the top layer of the PCB. These large areas of copper on the top layer are all connected to the 3.3V supply. The bottom layer of the board remains one big ground plane.

Copper fill stub near the oscillators on HW 2.2.

The copper fill near the oscillators looks especially suspicious. It was only connected to the 3.3V supply with a narrow bridge between the pins of P4 on the right. It provided supply voltage to U4 and nothing else further down to the left side. It seems like it could accidentally form a quarter-wave stub antenna. It's approximately 25 mm in length, so the resonance could well be somewhere in the GHz range. This is near enough to the 2.4 GHz band that I think it would be feasible for it transmit some oscillator harmonics out from the board.

It would be interesting to see if this stub was indeed causing the problems. It should be easy to drill a hole through and decouple the left end of it with a SMD capacitor to the ground plane on the bottom layer. I could then repeat the near-field measurements I did last year to confirm. I'm not sure if I will bother though. The new board does indeed fix the problem with the Raspberry Pi built-in Wi-Fi radio and I currently don't have any particular use for another audio board.

Posted by Tomaž | Categories: Analog

Comments

The sampling frequency unit is a little off, it's 44100 Hz, not kHz. Same for the 48000 Hz frequency.

Posted by EmilyFromFarAway

Emily, thanks. I fixed the unit.

Posted by Tomaž

Add a new comment


(No HTML tags allowed. Separate paragraphs with a blank line.)